I am and will always be a big fan of the “Dutch suffered serious brain trauma during the San Denis bank robbery/trolley car escape” theory. Things start going immediately downhill from there. It also plays into the game’s themes of poor decision making (the bank robbery was rushed) leads to destructive outcomes
The gloom of Grimmauld Place parted, and a gleaming silver doe walked towards Sirius. Her beautiful head tilted, and her long starlight lashes fluttered. Harry too. He literally gave you something to use in case you needed to contact him and instead you decide to break into the nazi’s office and then the department of fucking mysteries where your friend’s father was almost murdered a few months ago?